Meaning
Subjective dishonesty or conscious wrongdoing in the discharge of contractual or fiduciary obligations represents a departure from the implied covenant of fair dealing. In commercial transactions, bad faith arises when a party acts with an improper motive, deliberately violating the spirit of an agreement to undermine the counterparty’s expected benefits. This behaviour extends beyond poor judgement.
Intentional Breach
Contractual performance requires adherence to mutual expectations that preclude deceptive or evasive tactics. When a contracting entity engages in bad faith, the action often involves fabricating reasons for non-performance or exploiting ambiguous terms to escape liability. This conduct disrupts the commercial equilibrium established during negotiations.
Courts look at whether the breaching party acted with a dishonest purpose rather than a mistaken belief. Such distinctions determine whether punitive damages or fee-shifting remedies become available to the injured party.
Remedial Boundary
Damages for standard disputes focus on restoring the injured party to their expected position. Where bad faith is established, courts may award extra-contractual damages to address the dishonest conduct. These remedies operate as a financial penalty.
Evidentiary Standard
Proving subjective intent requires a high threshold of clear and convincing documentation since mere failure to perform does not establish a dishonest motive. Written communications, internal memos and sudden unexplained shifts in operational behaviour provide the necessary factual basis to demonstrate bad faith. This standard prevents parties from using allegations of dishonesty to escalate simple contract disputes into expensive tort litigation.