Meaning
Capital maintenance violation occurring when a cash payment for shares is immediately returned to the subscriber as payment for an asset. German and other European corporate laws treat a hidden in-kind contribution as an invalid performance of the obligation to pay for shares. The law requires that assets brought into a company undergo a formal valuation report to protect creditors.
Legal Nullity
Failure to disclose the non cash nature of the transaction results in the shareholder still owing the original cash amount. In the event of insolvency, a liquidator identifies a hidden in-kind contribution and demands the full payment of the share capital again. The asset already transferred to the company usually cannot be credited against this liability.
Remediation Method
Restoration of legal certainty requires the retroactive disclosure and valuation of the contributed asset. If the value of the asset at the time of the initial transaction met or exceeded the subscription price, the hidden in-kind contribution may be cured. This process involves filing a detailed report with the commercial register to transparently state the facts.
Liability Risk
Managing directors face personal liability for allowing the circumvention of capital rules. Because the integrity of the share capital is fundamental to corporate governance, a hidden in-kind contribution is viewed as a serious breach of fiduciary duty. Investors should ensure that all related party transactions at the time of incorporation or capital increases are documented as distinct and independent events.