Meaning
Transactions executed by a fiduciary for their own personal benefit rather than for the sole benefit of the principal or beneficiary constitute a breach of the duty of loyalty. In corporate and trust law, self dealing arises when a director or trustee buys corporate assets or sells personal property to the trust without proper authorization. This conduct creates an irreconcilable conflict of interest.
Transaction Avoidance
Courts treat such transactions as voidable at the option of the beneficiary regardless of whether the deal was fair or profitable. When a fiduciary engages in self dealing, the burden of proof shifts to them to demonstrate absolute fairness and full disclosure. If they cannot meet this high standard, the court will rescind the transaction and order the return of any profits.
This strict rule deters fiduciaries from exploiting their position of trust.
Safe Harbour
Fiduciaries can escape liability if they obtain prior, fully informed consent from all beneficiaries or independent directors. This disclosure must include every material detail of the transaction and the fiduciary’s interest in it. Approved transactions must still match market value.
Trustee Accountability
Restoring the trust’s assets ensures that fiduciaries remain focused on their primary obligations. Courts enforce disgorgement of profits and may remove the offending trustee or director from office. This consequence reinforces the high ethical standard demanded of corporate leaders.