Meaning
Comparisons between the financial relations of associated enterprises and those of independent entities form the basis of cross border profit adjustments. Transfer pricing article 9 introduces the arm’s length principle to prevent profit shifting across borders. It allows tax authorities to rewrite the accounts of a company to reflect the profits that would have been earned in an uncontrolled transaction.
Comparability Standard
Assessment of a transaction requires a comparison with similar deals made between unrelated parties. Factors like the functions performed, risks assumed, assets used and market conditions are all considered in the analysis. If the conditions do not match market reality, an adjustment is made.
Primary Adjustment
The tax office of one country increases the taxable profit of a local subsidiary if it paid too much for a service from its foreign parent. This change leads to a higher tax liability in that jurisdiction. Such corrections are common in audits of multinational corporations.
Double Taxation
Disputes often arise when two countries claim the right to tax the same profit due to differing views on the arm’s length price. Relief is typically sought through a mutual agreement procedure defined in the tax treaty. This mechanism aims to eliminate the fiscal burden on the company while ensuring both nations receive their fair share of revenue.
Successful resolution requires cooperation. The process can take several years and often involves the exchange of detailed economic data to reach a settlement.