Meaning
Contractual provisions in director and officer insurance policies and corporate indemnification agreements strip away protective coverage when a court determines that a representative acted with intentional dishonesty or conscious disregard for duties. These bad faith exclusions prevent the transfer of financial liability from the individual to the corporate treasury or the insurer when the conduct violates minimal standards of honest business behavior. The mechanism arises most frequently during derivative lawsuits where shareholders allege that directors deliberately ignored warning signs of corporate wrongdoing.
Carveout Trigger
The activation of these limitations requires a final, non-appealable adjudication of misconduct in the underlying action before the insurer can permanently deny coverage. Until such a judgment occurs, the company typically advances defence costs under a separate undertaking. This arrangement ensures that allegations alone do not deprive the director of the means to mount a legal defence.
Litigation Defence
Insured parties often negotiate narrow definitions of excluded conduct to preserve their indemnity. If the language covers broad categories of negligent behavior, directors risk personal ruin from routine business decisions that ended in failure. Clear drafting confines the exclusion to subjective intent or active fraud.
Pleading Hurdle
Plaintiff strategies frequently involve framing complaints to allege conscious misconduct to bypass statutory protections and access personal assets. This approach increases the pressure on defendants to settle before trial. A well-constructed indemnification agreement counters this pressure by maintaining the funding of the defence until the final judicial determination.