Meaning
Calculation of the financial compensation owed by a wrongful occupier of land to the rightful owner covers the period of unauthorized possession. When a tenant holds over after a lease expires, mesne profits accounting establishes the market rent value the owner lost during the occupancy. This legal action restores the owner to the financial position they would have held.
Rental Valuation
Evaluating the lost revenue depends on the prevailing market rates rather than the previous rent. In executing mesne profits accounting, courts assess the reasonable earning potential of the property during the wrongful stay. The defendant must pay this sum even if they derived no actual profit from using the land.
This ensures that the wrongdoer cannot benefit from their unauthorized presence.
Restitution Claim
Owners can claim additional damages for any physical deterioration of the property that occurred during the unlawful tenancy. This process ensures that mesne profits accounting covers both the lost usage value and any depreciation of the physical assets.
Defense Argument
Occupiers sometimes argue that the owner consented to the stay or delayed initiating eviction proceedings. If the court accepts these claims, the period of mesne profits accounting is shortened to exclude the consented duration.