Meaning
The question of whether the parties have satisfied the preliminary conditions required to submit their dispute to arbitration falls under the jurisdiction of the chosen tribunal. This procedural arbitrability determines whether the claim can proceed based on the fulfillment of contractual pre-requisites like notice periods or mediation sessions. It represents the boundary between procedural hurdles that arbitrators must resolve and substantive jurisdictional challenges that courts may decide.
Tribunal Competence
Arbitrators hold the authority to decide questions regarding the satisfaction of dispute resolution clauses. The doctrine of competence-competence allows the panel to assess procedural arbitrability before hearing the merits of the case. This prevents parties from delaying the process by raising procedural objections in court.
Timeliness Threshold
Contractual time limits for filing claims are common procedural hurdles in international commerce. If a claimant misses the filing deadline, the tribunal will evaluate the procedural arbitrability of the claim. A late filing may result in the dismissal of the action without any review of the substantive rights.
Judicial Review
Courts generally show great deference to an arbitral tribunal’s decisions on procedural matters. This means that a court will rarely overturn an award based on an arbitrator’s ruling on procedural arbitrability.