Meaning
Equitable remedies for contract breach provide a method for enforcing specific promises that cannot be satisfied by financial payments. A specific performance shareholder agreement clause allows a party to ask a court to force another shareholder to take a particular action. This is commonly used in disputes over board appointments or the transfer of shares.
Remedy Choice
Courts generally prefer to award damages for a breach of contract unless the subject matter is unique. In the case of a specific performance shareholder agreement, the rights involved are often considered unique because money cannot replace the control or influence lost. This remedy ensures that the actual bargain made by the investors is honored.
Board Control
Investors use these provisions to ensure that their chosen representatives are seated on the board of directors. When a shareholder refuses to cast their ballot in accordance with a previous voting covenant, a specific performance shareholder agreement allows the court to issue a mandatory injunction that dictates the exact manner in which those rights must be exercised. It prevents a hostile faction from seizing control through a simple breach of promise.
Judicial Constraint
The court will only grant this order if it is practical to enforce and does not cause undue hardship. A claim for a specific performance shareholder agreement might fail if the relationship between the parties has broken down so completely that a court order cannot fix it. The judge must balance the need for contract enforcement against the reality of ongoing corporate governance.